Engagement fell in 2024 and many workers feel uneasy about AI. A well-tested theory of motivation shows where a rollout can help or hurt.
Gallup’s State of the Global Workplace 2025, published April 22, 2025, reported that global employee engagement fell from 23% to 21% in 2024, only the second drop in 12 years after 2020 [1]. Gallup estimated the cost at US$438 billion in lost productivity [1].
Managers show the sharpest decline. Manager engagement fell from 30% to 27%, while individual contributors held flat at 18% [1]. Managers under 35 fell five points and female managers fell seven [1].
The tension is that AI tools save time on routine work while engagement falls and worry runs high [1][2]. Gallup lists AI tools among the disruptions affecting workplaces, alongside post-pandemic turnover, a hiring boom and bust, restructured teams, shrinking budgets, digital transformation and new demands for flexibility [1]. Self-Determination Theory offers a way to read that mix, because it ties motivation to three needs that a rollout can support or block [4].
Workers are anxious about what comes next. Pew Research Center’s February 25, 2025, survey of 5,273 employed US adults, fielded October 7 to 13, 2024, found that 52% feel worried about how AI may be used in the workplace in future, 36% hopeful, 33% overwhelmed and 29% excited [2]. Some 32% said AI will lead to fewer job opportunities for them, compared with 6% who said more [2].
The time savings are real for some. Of workers who used AI chatbots, 40% found them extremely or very helpful for doing things more quickly and 29% for improving quality [2]. Yet only 16% said at least some of their work is done with AI [2].
Self-Determination Theory explains why the same tool can lift or lower motivation. Ryan and Deci’s 2000 paper in American Psychologist (volume 55, pages 68-78) holds that conditions supporting autonomy, competence and relatedness support the highest-quality motivation and engagement, including performance, persistence and creativity [4]. When any of the three needs is thwarted, wellness suffers [4].
The theory’s authors tie autonomy to a sense of volition, competence to mastering challenges, and relatedness to close relationships and belonging to groups [4]. Their research also finds that rewards, interpersonal controls and ego-involvement can affect intrinsic motivation [4].
What the three needs look like at work
Autonomy is at risk when a rollout arrives as a mandate. Research in this tradition contrasts controlling environments with autonomy-supportive ones and links the second kind to better functioning, performance and persistence [4].
Competence is where leaders see the most upside. In Microsoft’s index, 83% of leaders said AI will enable employees to take on more complex work earlier in careers [3]. Workers are less sure: 32% of those Pew surveyed expect fewer job opportunities for them [2].
Relatedness runs through the manager: Gallup attributes 70% of team engagement to the manager [1]. Microsoft reported that 80% of the global workforce says it lacks the time or energy to do the job, with an interruption every two minutes on average [3]. One reading of those numbers is that crowded days leave little time for the conversations that build connection.

Where the evidence is thinner than it looks
Much of the data is US-only or comes from vendors. Pew’s survey covers 5,273 employed US adults, not a global sample [2]. Microsoft’s index blends survey, telemetry and LinkedIn data, and Microsoft sells the AI products the report discusses [3].
Engagement also fell for reasons that have nothing to do with AI. Gallup’s list includes post-pandemic turnover, a hiring boom and bust, restructured teams and shrinking budgets [1]. It places AI tools alongside those forces rather than above them [1].
How workers and managers can protect each need
Autonomy
Ask for input on which tasks the tool handles and which stay human, and let the person doing the work choose the method while the outcome stays fixed [4]. Autonomy-supportive conditions are linked to better persistence and performance [4].
Competence
Start with one routine task and judge the result yourself before widening use. Pew’s data suggests speed gains come more readily than quality gains: 40% of chatbot users found the tools extremely or very helpful for speed, and 29% for quality [2]. Pair adoption with training; the World Economic Forum reports that 50% of the workforce completed training as part of long-term learning strategies, up from 41% in 2023 [5].
Relatedness
Keep a short, regular human check-in about how the new tools are changing the work. A usage dashboard will not show how the work feels. Managers need support too: Gallup found engagement fell most sharply among managers under 35 (down five points) and female managers (down seven) [1].
Leaders are moving faster than their teams. In Microsoft’s survey, 82% of leaders expect to use digital labor, meaning AI agents, to expand their workforce within 12 to 18 months, and leaders expect teams will be training (41%) and managing (36%) agents within five years [3]. Some 67% of leaders are familiar with agents, compared with 40% of employees [3].
Employers expect 39% of workers’ core skills to change by 2030, down from 44% in 2023 [5]. Analytical thinking ranks as the top core skill, resilience, flexibility and agility second, and motivation and self-awareness fifth [5].
Watch the next Gallup and Pew releases to see whether engagement recovers as AI use spreads [1][2]. This week, pick one routine task, note how long it takes, and agree with your manager who decides whether the tool takes it over [4].
Related reading on Career Ahead
- The Future of Work: How Automation and AI Will Impact Jobs
- The Rise of Soft Skills in the Modern Workplace
- Satya Nadella’s AI Revolution: How Gen Z Can Thrive in Knowledge Work’s New Era
- Leading Change When Certainty Is Gone
Frequently asked questions
Did employee engagement actually fall in 2024?
Yes. Gallup reported global engagement fell from 23% to 21% in 2024, the second drop in 12 years, with 62% not engaged and 17% actively disengaged [1].
Do workers feel positive or negative about AI?
Both, in different shares. In Pew’s October 2024 survey, 52% felt worried, 36% hopeful, 33% overwhelmed and 29% excited about future workplace AI use [2]. About a third (32%) expected fewer job opportunities for them, while 6% expected more [2].
What does Self-Determination Theory say about motivation?
It holds that autonomy, competence and relatedness support the highest-quality motivation and engagement, and that blocking any of the three harms wellness [4]. Rewards, interpersonal controls and ego-involvement can affect intrinsic motivation [4].
Is the AI and engagement data reliable?
Partly. Pew’s sample covers 5,273 employed US adults, and Microsoft’s index comes from a company that sells AI products [2][3]. Gallup lists AI tools among several disruptions, not as the sole cause [1].
Sources
- Gallup, “Global Engagement Falls for the Second Time Since 2009” and State of the Global Workplace 2025 report, April 22, 2025. https://www.gallup.com/workplace/659279/global-engagement-falls-second-time-2009.aspx
- Pew Research Center, “U.S. Workers Are More Worried Than Hopeful About Future AI Use in the Workplace,” February 25, 2025. https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2025/02/25/u-s-workers-are-more-worried-than-hopeful-about-future-ai-use-in-the-workplace/
- Microsoft, “The 2025 Annual Work Trend Index: The Frontier Firm is born,” April 23, 2025. https://blogs.microsoft.com/blog/2025/04/23/the-2025-annual-work-trend-index-the-frontier-firm-is-born/
- Center for Self-Determination Theory, “Theory” overview, citing Ryan and Deci (2000), American Psychologist 55, 68-78. https://selfdeterminationtheory.org/theory/
- World Economic Forum, Future of Jobs Report 2025, chapter 3: Skills outlook, January 2025. https://www.weforum.org/publications/the-future-of-jobs-report-2025/in-full/3-skills-outlook/
This article was prepared with AI assistance and edited and fact-checked by Poornima Singh, Career Ahead.






