Career Ahead Magazine
Subscribe
Entrepreneurship & Business

What Nithin Kamath’s Tax-Arbitrage Argument Actually Means for Startup Employees

Zerodha's Nithin Kamath argues that taking cash out as a dividend is taxed much more heavily than selling shares for a capital gain, which he calls a tax arbitrage game. This article sets his 52% and 14.95% figures beside the official capital-gains rates and Grover's reply.

A person compares stock-market charts on a laptop and a smartphone.
Photo: Hanna Pad / Pexels

Zerodha’s Nithin Kamath says India’s tax rules reward growth and an exit over profits. Here is what he argued, how Ashneer Grover replied, and what the official rates actually are.

In a 3 November 2025 post, Zerodha co-founder Nithin Kamath argued that India’s tax structure makes it more attractive to take money out of a business as a capital gain than as a dividend. He said that gap encourages investors, especially venture-capital funds, to “burn” cash to grow a company and then sell shares, rather than build a profitable business that pays dividends.[1] The post was widely discussed among students and early-career workers who hold, or may be offered, employee stock options.

This article explains Kamath’s argument in his own figures, Grover’s reply, and the official capital-gains rates published by the Central Board of Direct Taxes and the Income Tax Department. The 52% and 14.95% numbers are Kamath’s illustrations, not official rates.[1][3][4] This is general information, not tax advice. Confirm your own position with a chartered accountant.

At a glance

  • Kamath puts the effective tax on taking cash out as a dividend at 52%, combining a 25% corporate tax and a 35.5% personal tax.[1]
  • He puts the tax on a capital-gain exit at 14.95%, with cess, and calls the gap a “tax arbitrage game.”[1]
  • For transfers on or after 23 July 2024, long-term capital gains on specified listed securities, where securities transaction tax is paid, are taxed at 12.5% above Rs 1.25 lakh. Short-term gains on those securities are taxed at 20%.[3][4]
  • Unlisted shares need a 24-month holding period for long-term treatment. Other long-term gains are taxed at 12.5% without indexation from that date.[3][4]
  • Ashneer Grover challenged the logic in a 5 November 2025 post, asking whether investors should then wait for dividends and whether brokers would still be in business.[2]

What did Nithin Kamath actually argue?

Kamath argued that taking cash out as dividends carries a much higher tax burden than selling shares for a capital gain, which he says encourages investors to chase growth and an exit rather than profits. In his 3 November 2025 post, he put the combined tax on a dividend at 52% and the tax on a capital-gain exit at 14.95% with cess.[1]

He arrives at 52% by adding a 25% corporate tax to a 35.5% personal tax on dividends.[1] The strategy he describes is to keep reported profits low, spend on acquiring users, build a growth story, and then sell shares at a higher valuation while paying a lower tax than a dividend would attract.[1] He also argued that this makes businesses less resilient, and that unprofitable growth can be valued at higher multiples than steady profits.[1] The important limit is that 52% and 14.95% are his calculations, not rates set out in the CBDT FAQs or the department explainer.[1][3][4]

Tax forms, receipts and coins spread on a table beside a calculator and paperwork.
Photo: Nataliya Vaitkevich / Pexels

How did Ashneer Grover reply?

Ashneer Grover, the co-founder of BharatPe, challenged Kamath’s logic in a 5 November 2025 post reported by Business Today on 8 November. He asked whether, under that logic, investors should put money into a business and wait for dividend returns rather than selling shares for a capital gain, and whether Zerodha or any other broker would still be in business then.[2]

Grover’s question is a practical one, not a restatement of the official tax rates. If investors only waited for dividends, the share sales that brokers handle would be less central to how people cash out.[2] It does not settle whether Kamath’s 52% and 14.95% figures are the right way to describe the law. Those figures still have to be checked against the official rates below.[3][4]

How does India tax listed and unlisted share sales now?

For transfers on or after 23 July 2024, long-term capital gains on specified listed securities, where securities transaction tax is paid, are taxed at 12.5% above Rs 1.25 lakh, and short-term gains on those securities are taxed at 20%. Unlisted shares need a 24-month holding period for long-term treatment. Listed securities qualify as long-term after 12 months.[3][4]

The CBDT FAQs issued on 24 July 2024 say the new provisions came into force from 23 July 2024. For STT-paid listed equity, equity-oriented mutual funds and business-trust units, the short-term rate rose from 15% to 20% and the long-term rate rose from 10% to 12.5%. The section 112A exemption limit rose from Rs 1 lakh to Rs 1.25 lakh, applying for financial year 2024-25 and subsequent years.[3]

Other long-term capital gains were set at 12.5% without indexation, compared with 20% with indexation earlier.[3] The department’s capital-gains explainer, accessed on 17 November 2026, still lists those headline rates, plus surcharge and health and education cess. It also notes a grandfathering option at 20% with indexation for resident individuals and Hindu undivided families on land or buildings acquired before 23 July 2024.[4] Short-term gains on assets other than specified listed securities are generally taxed at slab rates.[4] Surcharge and cess can raise the effective rate above the headline 12.5% or 20%, but this article does not reconstruct those slabs.[4]

A close stack of Indian rupee banknotes on a dark surface.
Photo: Pranav Choubey / Pexels

How should a reader treat Kamath’s 52% and 14.95% figures?

Treat both numbers as Kamath’s own illustrations, not as official rates published by the tax department. He arrives at 52% by combining a 25% corporate tax with a 35.5% personal tax on dividends, and he describes the capital-gains figure as 14.95% with cess.[1] The official headline rates are those in the CBDT FAQs and the department’s capital-gains explainer.[3][4]

A reader who adds cess, or surcharge and cess, to the 12.5% long-term rate will get a higher effective number than 12.5%. Kamath’s 14.95% is his figure, including cess as he described it, and it should not be treated as a statutory rate.[1][4] The 52% dividend figure is also his combination of corporate and personal tax, and it will not apply in the same way to every company or every shareholder.[1]

What does this debate mean if you work at a startup or hold ESOPs?

If you hold employee stock options, the debate is a reminder that selling shares and receiving a dividend are taxed under different rules. Official capital-gains rates depend on whether the shares are listed, how long you hold them, and whether surcharge and cess apply.[3][4]

That is not a reason to assume a capital-gain exit will always be available, or that it will be taxed at Kamath’s 14.95% figure.[1] Unlisted shares still need a 24-month holding period for long-term treatment, and a sale before that is generally taxed at slab rates.[3][4] A growth-and-exit strategy can also fail to produce a sale at all, which is the practical risk for an employee whose compensation is tied to a future listing or buyout. Before you treat options as a substitute for salary, read the grant terms and get advice on the tax events that apply to you.

Related reading on Career Ahead

  • Moving Abroad From India: A Money Checklist Before You Become an NRI
  • What Is Agentic AI? A Plain-English Guide for Students and Early-Career Workers

Frequently asked questions

Is dividend income always taxed higher than capital gains?

Not by a single official combined rate. Kamath’s example puts the effective tax on a dividend at 52% and the tax on a capital-gain exit at 14.95% with cess. The official headline long-term rate on specified listed securities, for transfers on or after 23 July 2024, is 12.5% above Rs 1.25 lakh, plus surcharge and cess, and the short-term rate on those securities is 20%.

Do the new capital-gains rules apply to all share sales?

The changes described in the CBDT FAQs apply to transfers on or after 23 July 2024. Listed securities have a 12-month holding period for long-term treatment, and unlisted shares have a 24-month holding period. The 12.5% long-term rate without indexation applies from that date, with the land-and-building grandfathering option noted above.

Can I claim the exemption limit on capital gains?

The section 112A exemption limit for specified listed securities is Rs 1.25 lakh for financial year 2024-25 and subsequent years, according to the CBDT FAQs. Gains above that threshold are taxed at the 12.5% rate, plus surcharge and cess, when the stated conditions are met.

Should I wait for a capital-gain exit instead of taking a dividend?

The official headline rates on specified listed-security capital gains are lower than the combined corporate-plus-personal tax in Kamath’s dividend example, but the effective rate depends on listing, holding period, surcharge and cess, and on whether a sale actually happens. That is a personal tax and career decision, not a rule of thumb this article can settle.

Sources

  1. Nithin Kamath, “How India’s tax structure rewards growth over profits,” 3 November 2025. https://nithinkamath.me/blog/how-indias-tax-structure-rewards-growth-over-profits/
  2. Business Today, “Would Zerodha still be in business then?: Ashneer Grover challenges Nithin Kamath’s tax logic,” updated 8 November 2025, quoting Grover’s 5 November 2025 post. https://www.businesstoday.in/latest/trends/story/would-zerodha-still-be-in-business-then-ashneer-grover-challenges-nithin-kamaths-tax-logic-501330-2025-11-08
  3. Press Information Bureau / CBDT, “FAQs issued by CBDT on the new capital gains tax regime proposed in the Union Budget 2024-25,” 24 July 2024, PRID 2036604. https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=2036604
  4. Income Tax Department, “Capital Gain” explainer, accessed 17 November 2026. https://www.incometaxindia.gov.in/w/capital-gain

This article was prepared with AI assistance and edited and fact-checked by Poornima Singh, Career Ahead.

Share this story
Career Ahead Editorial Team

Written by

Newsroom, Career Ahead Magazine

The Career Ahead Editorial Team is the newsroom of Career Ahead Magazine, a career and leadership title in print and online since July 2020. Our editors report and edit the interviews and career guides that first-person contributors don't write. You'll find us writing for students choosing what to study and for professionals planning their next move. We also cover founders…

Career Ahead follows strict sourcing and fact-checking standards. About our editorial standards.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

→

More in Entrepreneurship & Business

View all →
Entrepreneurship & Business

When Did Speaking to a Human Become So Hard?

A shipment of 20 prepaid packages that never arrived. A stolen phone (sim) that took a public post to replace. Why getting…

Connect with us

Say hello →

Be Ahead

Sign up for our newsletter

Get regular updates directly in your inbox!

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.