Zerodha’s Nithin Kamath says India’s tax rules reward growth and an exit over profits. Here is what he argued, how Ashneer Grover replied, and what the official rates actually are.
In a 3 November 2025 post, Zerodha co-founder Nithin Kamath argued that India’s tax structure makes it more attractive to take money out of a business as a capital gain than as a dividend. He said that gap encourages investors, especially venture-capital funds, to “burn” cash to grow a company and then sell shares, rather than build a profitable business that pays dividends.[1] The post was widely discussed among students and early-career workers who hold, or may be offered, employee stock options.
This article explains Kamath’s argument in his own figures, Grover’s reply, and the official capital-gains rates published by the Central Board of Direct Taxes and the Income Tax Department. The 52% and 14.95% numbers are Kamath’s illustrations, not official rates.[1][3][4] This is general information, not tax advice. Confirm your own position with a chartered accountant.
At a glance
- Kamath puts the effective tax on taking cash out as a dividend at 52%, combining a 25% corporate tax and a 35.5% personal tax.[1]
- He puts the tax on a capital-gain exit at 14.95%, with cess, and calls the gap a “tax arbitrage game.”[1]
- For transfers on or after 23 July 2024, long-term capital gains on specified listed securities, where securities transaction tax is paid, are taxed at 12.5% above Rs 1.25 lakh. Short-term gains on those securities are taxed at 20%.[3][4]
- Unlisted shares need a 24-month holding period for long-term treatment. Other long-term gains are taxed at 12.5% without indexation from that date.[3][4]
- Ashneer Grover challenged the logic in a 5 November 2025 post, asking whether investors should then wait for dividends and whether brokers would still be in business.[2]
What did Nithin Kamath actually argue?
Kamath argued that taking cash out as dividends carries a much higher tax burden than selling shares for a capital gain, which he says encourages investors to chase growth and an exit rather than profits. In his 3 November 2025 post, he put the combined tax on a dividend at 52% and the tax on a capital-gain exit at 14.95% with cess.[1]
He arrives at 52% by adding a 25% corporate tax to a 35.5% personal tax on dividends.[1] The strategy he describes is to keep reported profits low, spend on acquiring users, build a growth story, and then sell shares at a higher valuation while paying a lower tax than a dividend would attract.[1] He also argued that this makes businesses less resilient, and that unprofitable growth can be valued at higher multiples than steady profits.[1] The important limit is that 52% and 14.95% are his calculations, not rates set out in the CBDT FAQs or the department explainer.[1][3][4]

How did Ashneer Grover reply?
Ashneer Grover, the co-founder of BharatPe, challenged Kamath’s logic in a 5 November 2025 post reported by Business Today on 8 November. He asked whether, under that logic, investors should put money into a business and wait for dividend returns rather than selling shares for a capital gain, and whether Zerodha or any other broker would still be in business then.[2]
Grover’s question is a practical one, not a restatement of the official tax rates. If investors only waited for dividends, the share sales that brokers handle would be less central to how people cash out.[2] It does not settle whether Kamath’s 52% and 14.95% figures are the right way to describe the law. Those figures still have to be checked against the official rates below.[3][4]
How does India tax listed and unlisted share sales now?
For transfers on or after 23 July 2024, long-term capital gains on specified listed securities, where securities transaction tax is paid, are taxed at 12.5% above Rs 1.25 lakh, and short-term gains on those securities are taxed at 20%. Unlisted shares need a 24-month holding period for long-term treatment. Listed securities qualify as long-term after 12 months.[3][4]
The CBDT FAQs issued on 24 July 2024 say the new provisions came into force from 23 July 2024. For STT-paid listed equity, equity-oriented mutual funds and business-trust units, the short-term rate rose from 15% to 20% and the long-term rate rose from 10% to 12.5%. The section 112A exemption limit rose from Rs 1 lakh to Rs 1.25 lakh, applying for financial year 2024-25 and subsequent years.[3]
Other long-term capital gains were set at 12.5% without indexation, compared with 20% with indexation earlier.[3] The department’s capital-gains explainer, accessed on 17 November 2026, still lists those headline rates, plus surcharge and health and education cess. It also notes a grandfathering option at 20% with indexation for resident individuals and Hindu undivided families on land or buildings acquired before 23 July 2024.[4] Short-term gains on assets other than specified listed securities are generally taxed at slab rates.[4] Surcharge and cess can raise the effective rate above the headline 12.5% or 20%, but this article does not reconstruct those slabs.[4]

How should a reader treat Kamath’s 52% and 14.95% figures?
Treat both numbers as Kamath’s own illustrations, not as official rates published by the tax department. He arrives at 52% by combining a 25% corporate tax with a 35.5% personal tax on dividends, and he describes the capital-gains figure as 14.95% with cess.[1] The official headline rates are those in the CBDT FAQs and the department’s capital-gains explainer.[3][4]
A reader who adds cess, or surcharge and cess, to the 12.5% long-term rate will get a higher effective number than 12.5%. Kamath’s 14.95% is his figure, including cess as he described it, and it should not be treated as a statutory rate.[1][4] The 52% dividend figure is also his combination of corporate and personal tax, and it will not apply in the same way to every company or every shareholder.[1]
What does this debate mean if you work at a startup or hold ESOPs?
If you hold employee stock options, the debate is a reminder that selling shares and receiving a dividend are taxed under different rules. Official capital-gains rates depend on whether the shares are listed, how long you hold them, and whether surcharge and cess apply.[3][4]
That is not a reason to assume a capital-gain exit will always be available, or that it will be taxed at Kamath’s 14.95% figure.[1] Unlisted shares still need a 24-month holding period for long-term treatment, and a sale before that is generally taxed at slab rates.[3][4] A growth-and-exit strategy can also fail to produce a sale at all, which is the practical risk for an employee whose compensation is tied to a future listing or buyout. Before you treat options as a substitute for salary, read the grant terms and get advice on the tax events that apply to you.
Related reading on Career Ahead
- Moving Abroad From India: A Money Checklist Before You Become an NRI
- What Is Agentic AI? A Plain-English Guide for Students and Early-Career Workers
Frequently asked questions
Is dividend income always taxed higher than capital gains?
Not by a single official combined rate. Kamath’s example puts the effective tax on a dividend at 52% and the tax on a capital-gain exit at 14.95% with cess. The official headline long-term rate on specified listed securities, for transfers on or after 23 July 2024, is 12.5% above Rs 1.25 lakh, plus surcharge and cess, and the short-term rate on those securities is 20%.
Do the new capital-gains rules apply to all share sales?
The changes described in the CBDT FAQs apply to transfers on or after 23 July 2024. Listed securities have a 12-month holding period for long-term treatment, and unlisted shares have a 24-month holding period. The 12.5% long-term rate without indexation applies from that date, with the land-and-building grandfathering option noted above.
Can I claim the exemption limit on capital gains?
The section 112A exemption limit for specified listed securities is Rs 1.25 lakh for financial year 2024-25 and subsequent years, according to the CBDT FAQs. Gains above that threshold are taxed at the 12.5% rate, plus surcharge and cess, when the stated conditions are met.
Should I wait for a capital-gain exit instead of taking a dividend?
The official headline rates on specified listed-security capital gains are lower than the combined corporate-plus-personal tax in Kamath’s dividend example, but the effective rate depends on listing, holding period, surcharge and cess, and on whether a sale actually happens. That is a personal tax and career decision, not a rule of thumb this article can settle.
Sources
- Nithin Kamath, “How India’s tax structure rewards growth over profits,” 3 November 2025. https://nithinkamath.me/blog/how-indias-tax-structure-rewards-growth-over-profits/
- Business Today, “Would Zerodha still be in business then?: Ashneer Grover challenges Nithin Kamath’s tax logic,” updated 8 November 2025, quoting Grover’s 5 November 2025 post. https://www.businesstoday.in/latest/trends/story/would-zerodha-still-be-in-business-then-ashneer-grover-challenges-nithin-kamaths-tax-logic-501330-2025-11-08
- Press Information Bureau / CBDT, “FAQs issued by CBDT on the new capital gains tax regime proposed in the Union Budget 2024-25,” 24 July 2024, PRID 2036604. https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=2036604
- Income Tax Department, “Capital Gain” explainer, accessed 17 November 2026. https://www.incometaxindia.gov.in/w/capital-gain
This article was prepared with AI assistance and edited and fact-checked by Poornima Singh, Career Ahead.






